🤝 Choosing & hiring

Do I Really Need a Website If I Have Instagram?

Do I Really Need a Website If I Have Instagram?

TL;DR

  • Your Instagram page isn’t yours. Meta, the company that owns Instagram, writes the rules. It can change them or close your account.
  • How many of your followers see a post isn’t up to you. Instagram decides.
  • A website is the one place online that belongs to you: its address, its texts, and the messages people send you through it.
  • People reach a website in many ways: from Google, from the address on your card, from a friend’s tip, from a link on Instagram. If one way closes, the others stay open.
  • On Google, people search for someone to hire right now. On Instagram, they’re mostly just scrolling.
  • You don’t have to choose. On Instagram, people get to know you. On your website, they find your prices and details and decide whether to call you.

The Question That Comes Up Sooner or Later

You’ve been on Instagram for a while. You post regularly and answer messages. You have 2,000 followers, maybe 5,000 or 10,000. Clients tell you, “We found you on Instagram.” That feels good.

Say you run a salon and post photos of your work every day. Or you’re a tradesperson posting before-and-after shots. Instagram works: likes, messages and bookings come in. Why pay for a website when your Instagram page costs nothing?

The short answer: your Instagram page isn’t yours. Here’s what that means in practice.


Your Instagram Page Is Like a Rented Apartment

Picture two people. One rents an apartment, the other owns one. The rented apartment may be lovely, and the landlord may be friendly. But the landlord can raise the rent, change the locks or sell the apartment. The apartment you own may be smaller, but nobody can throw you out.

It’s the same with Instagram, Facebook and TikTok. You’ve furnished your page with posts and invited people in. But the landlord is the social network.

Instagram belongs to Meta. Meta decides:

  • who sees your posts;
  • which posts to hide if they break Instagram’s rules;
  • whether to close your account: sometimes one complaint, or one mistake by Instagram’s automatic checks, is enough;
  • whether the social network itself will still exist in five years. Remember Vine and Google+: both closed long ago, and the pages on them went too.

A website is like an apartment you own. You decide what it says, how it looks and how fast it opens. The site’s files are yours. The domain, your site’s address, is registered in your name.

There are rules here too. Your site is stored with a hosting company, a company that keeps sites on the internet. Your domain is bought from a registrar, a company that sells domains. So you’ll have two accounts: one with the hosting company and one with the registrar. Guard the logins to both: a strong password, and two-step login with a code on your phone.


Who Decides Whether People See Your Post

Instagram decides who sees your posts and in what order. A program makes that decision; it’s called the algorithm.

Instagram says there’s no single algorithm. Feed, Stories, Explore, Reels and Search each have their own rules (Instagram, May 2023). In Feed, Instagram looks at what each follower does in the app and what it knows about the post. It also looks at how often that follower likes your posts, comments on them or messages you.

The rules change from time to time. Today Instagram shows more videos; tomorrow, something else. If you’ve been making one kind of post and Instagram now favors another, fewer people see yours. There are usually two ways to win those viewers back: pay for ads, or make whatever is in fashion now.

Google has rules too. Google decides which sites to show higher, and those rules change as well. But a website has many roads leading to it. People come from Google, type in the address from your card, get a link from a friend or from your Instagram. If your site drops lower in Google, the other roads are still there.

And if all you have is Instagram, and the rules suddenly change? Then there’s only one road to you, and nothing to fall back on.


What’s Yours on Instagram, and What’s Yours on a Website

On Instagram:

  • Your followers. Instagram can remove some of them, for example fake accounts.
  • Your posts. Instagram can hide or delete a post, sometimes without warning.
  • How many people see your posts. Instagram decides.
  • Your account. It can be blocked or hacked, and getting it back can be hard.
  • Your link to clients. You don’t have your followers’ email addresses or phone numbers. Lose the account, and you lose touch with them.

On your website:

  • Your texts and photos. You decide what to put up, change or take down. The hosting company’s rules and the law still apply, of course.
  • How the site looks. The design, the order of the pages, the texts: all your call.
  • The roads to you. Google, the address on your card, a friend’s tip, a link from social media.
  • Visitor statistics. You can see how many people visit, if you add a statistics tool. In the EU, many of these tools need visitors’ consent first.
  • Your contacts. Messages from your site’s form arrive in your inbox. If people agree to get your newsletter, you can take their addresses with you to any newsletter service.

On Instagram, you’re a guest. On your own website, you’re at home.


What a Website Gives You That Instagram Doesn’t

People Who Need You Right Now Can Find You

Google search is the biggest difference, and the one people most often forget.

Instagram shows your posts mostly to your followers. They usually scroll their feed between other things, to take a break. New people see you if a post happens to spread (you can’t count on that) or if you pay for ads.

Google is different. Someone types “hairdresser near me”, “plumber Limassol” or “wedding photographer Berlin”. That person isn’t relaxing. They have something to sort out, and they want someone who can help right now. A person like that is worth far more than a follower who likes a post and scrolls on.

A website helps you show up in those searches. You can appear on Google Maps without a website, through a free Google Business Profile (your free listing on Google Maps and in search). But a website tells both Google and the person searching much more. How to get found on Google Maps →

Your Clients’ Contacts Stay With You

Followers don’t give you their email or phone number. If your account were blocked tomorrow, your 2,000 followers would be gone. You’d have nowhere to write to them. You’d start from scratch.

On a website, people can write to you through the form or sign up for your newsletter. If they’ve agreed to it, their address stays with you. You can keep writing to them, even if every social network changed its rules tomorrow.

Everything in One Place

On Instagram, everything comes in the same shape: posts, short captions, a couple of lines about you and a few links. Your prices are in a post from three months ago. Your best review was in Stories and has already vanished. How you work is scattered across the captions of old posts.

A website keeps everything in one place: prices, photos of your work, how you work, reviews, answers to common questions and a contact form. Nothing slides down out of sight or disappears.

An Address That Doesn’t Change

Your Instagram name can change, and social networks come and go. A domain like yourname.eu stays yours for as long as you renew it. A domain costs from €10–15 a year (what a domain costs). You can put it on your cards, your van, your shop window and your email signature.

A Website Doesn’t Need New Posts Every Day

A social network wants your attention every day. Posts sink quickly, and to stay visible you have to keep posting new ones. That takes a lot of time.

A website works without you. It’s built once, and then it answers your clients’ usual questions while you sleep, work or take a break. You only change it when something changes for you.


”But My Clients Find Me on Instagram”

That’s great. Instagram is excellent for letting people get to know you. There, they see your work and your personality, and decide whether they like you.

But on Instagram, it’s harder for people to make up their minds and book. Someone is interested and wants to know more: what you do, what it costs, when you’re free. If they have to send a message and wait for a reply, many won’t. They’ll scroll on and forget about you.

A website answers those questions straight away. Your services, prices, address and reviews are all on one page. That’s where people decide whether to call you.

Together, it works like this:

  • On Instagram, people notice you. You show your work and remind them you exist.
  • On your website, people who got interested find your prices, reviews and a way to book.

You can put the link to your site in your Instagram profile, in Stories and in your captions. You don’t have to choose between Instagram and a website; it’s best to have both. But if you only have the time and energy for one, put it into the one that belongs to you.


What It Costs to Go Without a Website

Every month, people in your town search Google for what you do: “plumber near me”, “wedding photographer Barcelona”, “bakery near me”. The ones who find a clear website with prices and a phone number call. Without a website, you can only hope they somehow find your Instagram.

Let’s work it out with an invented example. A kitchen fitter works in a small town. Every day, five to ten people search Google for “kitchen fitting”. They don’t find this fitter: the only place to learn about him is Instagram. Instead, they find a competitor with a simple website: photos of past work, a contact form, a phone number.

Say just one of those searches a month could have turned into a job. Then over a year, the fitter loses twelve jobs. If a job is worth a few thousand euros, that’s a lot of money.

For a café, it’s passers-by who searched for “coffee near me” and never heard of you. For a therapist, it’s people looking for help late in the evening, when you’ve stopped answering messages.

These people aren’t scrolling out of boredom. They have something to sort out. They open the first site that looks trustworthy, read it and call. If you’re not in the search results, they go to someone else. Not because the other person is better, but because the other person was found.


What to Do Next

The good news: a simple website doesn’t have to be expensive or complicated.

  1. Don’t give up Instagram. Keep posting and talking to people as before. Instagram is still the best way to stay in people’s minds.
  2. Get a website. One page is enough. You’ll have a permanent address, a place for your prices and details, and a chance to show up on Google.
  3. Link your website and Instagram. Put the link to your site in your Instagram profile, mention the site in Stories, and add the address to your email signature.

If you’re choosing what to build your site with, compare the options: Wix, Squarespace or a developer. That post covers the pros, the cons and the prices of each route.

If one page is what you need, our Starter plan costs €150 plus VAT, once. It includes:

  • one page with up to six sections, made from your texts and photos;
  • a privacy policy page and a legal notice page;
  • free hosting: the site is stored with Cloudflare, a company that stores websites. Its free plan is enough for almost every site.

The site is made of ready-made pages, so there are no programs in it that need updating. See the plans →

A website won’t solve everything by itself. But it’s your place online, and it stays yours as long as you renew your domain. Your Instagram followers go there when they’re ready to book. And strangers who need you right now find you there.